Very often we hear politicians and pundits alike discuss the need to reduce the amount of bureaucracy we face. And yet, at this point, it is more of a slogan than an actual answer to the problem...
Very often we hear politicians and pundits alike discuss the need to reduce the amount of bureaucracy we face. And yet, at this point, it is more of a slogan than an actual answer to the problem. The reality is that, with so much red tape in existence, it is hard to know where to start, least of all because most regulation comes from a place of good intentions. Politicians aren’t necessarily regulating for the sake of regulation, but in response to their constituents demands.
However, this reflexive approach to regulation can often have unintended consequences. As such it can be hard to tell where to start when it comes to what regulations should be cut and which parts of the bureaucracy should be targeted.
This is where the Index of Bureaucracy comes in. Produced by Dr Sary Levy-Carciente of the Adam Smith Center for Economic Freedom at the Florida International University, it takes a look not at the specific regulations in question, but at their impact on business as measured through hours required to set up, run, and close down a business.
In the first instance, the index measures the number of hours needed to set up a new business. For example, the regulatory burden for setting up a new business in Brazil is just 334 working hours (or 13 continuous days) whilst in Peru (the second worst on the index) its 3,853 working hours, or almost half a calendar year. In effect the lower the number of hours, the better it is for business. On average, across the study the amount of time needed to start a new company is 9.5 working months.
The primary sector (e.g. agriculture, mining, fishing, oil/gas extraction) unsurprisingly represents the greatest share of the burden. This is in part due to high demands on licencing from the government, environmental regulation, and safety. However, the tertiary sector (e.g. financial services, tourism, retail, education) comes in second place.
The next metric measured in the index is the number of hours spent on the day-to-day administration of running a business. Again, there are wide variations here, with Honduras (the lowest) spending only 242 hours on regulatory administration, against Jamaica (the highest) which spends 3,238 or 134 days. The average across all case studies represents 57% of an employee’s annual working time being spent on regulation.
The novelty of this approach is that it can quantify the opportunity cost that over-regulation imposes on business. When a company spends excessive amounts of time dealing with administrative burden, it loses time on other more productive elements of running a business. According to Dr Sary Levy-Carciente, the current regulatory burden on average represents around 40% of company executive’s time.
To put that lost time into financial terms, Dr Levy-Carciente estimates that on average across the case studies around $33 billion is being lost to compliance, and $140 billion in labour productivity. This in turn represents as much as 16% of GDP across the board. What cannot be measured however is the lost output of companies that were never started as the regulatory burden considered too great.
Something else that ought to be considered, is that this high regulatory burden on small and medium sized enterprises advantages larger multi-national corporations who can more easily shoulder the cost of having a big compliance team. In some ways this opens the door for crony-capitalism, and for larger companies to even lobby for uncompetitive regulation in order to defend their market position against newcomers.
The final metric looked at in the report is the amount of time it takes to close a business at the end. Paradoxically, on average this takes twice as long as setting up a new business. With the worst offender being the Dominican Republic where it can take 19,000 hours or 2.5 years to wind-up a company.
Europe is often the target of criticism for over-regulation and placing a high administrative burden on companies. Yet the picture painted in the index is far more complex, highlighting a greater degree of variation. This is in part due to policy differences at the national level – especially when it comes to establishing new companies.
For example, France, Italy, and Portugal occupy the first, second, and fourth spots when it comes to the least number of hours required to establish new companies – usually just over a week. In effect putting them in a position where it is easier to start new businesses. Whilst Germany is the worst performing country on the current index at 3,942 hours or almost two working years.
Equally when it comes to regulation required to run a company in Europe, Ukraine, Spain, the United Kingdom remain relatively low, whilst Germany again sees a much higher burden.
This is explained by different countries approaches to support for SMEs. Portugal for example, sits comfortably at the low end of the scale, in part because it has made starting a running a business easier in order to attract the so called ‘digital nomads’ to settle. France, under Macron, made it easier to start new companies as a means of driving economic growth.
Whilst Dr Levy-Carciente praises Italy as the most improved country, that has seen the number of hours required across the board drop, and their ranking has improved several positions since last year when the Italian government led by Meloni made a concerted effort to streamline the regulation required to set up and run a company. The main change that has helped to improve the Italian governments standing is the digitalisation of the company registration process, and the introduction of a self-certifying and self-reporting system that turns the government into a auditor rather than a gate keeper.
Whilst EU regulations may play a role a large part of the burden also arrives in the form of national and even local regulation. Of course, this is not to say that much of this regulation isn’t either needed or wanted. For example, safety regulation could be seen more as an investment than a cost, given that it is better to have safe workers than pay for injured ones.
Indeed, the real test is to look at how the non-EU European countries compared to the EU Member States. Ukraine for example scores on the lower end of both establishing and running a business, in part because of economic reforms that have taken place in the country since the revolution of dignity in 2014, and in particular with the election of the Zelensky in 2019 who promised to streamline regulation in order to make administration less corrupt and more transparent.
Whilst former EU Member State the United Kingdom continues to score around the average range of setting up a business, and at the low range of running one. This is despite the UK’s promise to de-regulate post-Brexit. The higher time cost of setting up a business in the UK is partly down to overzealous anti-money laundering banking regulations that make setting up an account slow.
With de-regulation high on the political agenda around the world, including in the EU with the response to the Draghi Report, this index may serve as a useful tool to look at where the burden really lies. And to make a calculation as to whether particular regulations need to be kept or can be removed. But more to the point, it offers an opportunity to study how some countries have streamlined the costs and why others have failed to do so, and to measure the impact that has had on economic growth and innovation. This will tell a much bigger story as more and more countries are added to the Index in the coming years.
The full Index, with country specific profiles, can be read here.